20. Replacing Ball When Original Spot Not Known
Current Rule: If a player’s ball at rest anywhere off the putting green is lifted or moved under a Rule that requires the ball to be replaced:
Ø The ball must be replaced by placing it on its original spot (Rule 20-3a).
Ø But if the ball’s exact original spot is not known, the player must get the ball back into play not by placing it but by dropping it as near as possible to the ball’s estimated original spot (Rule 20-3c).
Proposed Rule: Under new Rule 14.2c, in that same situation:
Ø The ball would always be placed on a spot rather than being dropped.
Ø If the exact original spot is not known, the player would be required to replace the ball on its estimated spot (including on, under or against any attached natural objects that the ball had been at rest on, under or against).
Reasons for Change:
Ø A fundamental principle of golf is to play the ball as it lies; so this should mean that, when a ball at rest is moved, it should be returned to and played from its original spot or as close to that original spot as possible.
Ø When a player marks the ball’s spot with a ball-marker before lifting the ball, the original spot is known and the ball is replaced on the marked spot.
Ø But when a ball is accidentally moved, the player may not know the exact original spot:
o Currently, if the ball was at rest anywhere off the putting green, the player must drop the ball as near as possible to its estimated spot and play the ball from where it comes to rest (unless it rolls to where it must be re-dropped under Rule 20-2c).
o This means that the ball will often not be played from the estimated spot, as the dropped ball is allowed to roll as much as two-club lengths away from that spot.
o It also means that the ball may end up being played from a better or worse lie than the original lie (such as when the original spot was in the rough and the dropped ball comes to rest in the fairway, or vice versa; or when the ball had been at rest in deep grass and the dropped ball comes to rest on top of the grass).
Ø Requiring the player to replace the ball on the estimated spot (including being required to replace the ball on, under or against any fixed or growing things it had been at rest on, under or against) would help make sure the ball is played from as close as possible to its original spot and from the same or almost the same lie.
Ø Replacing the ball on its estimated spot also applies when the player does not know the exact original spot of a ball that was lifted or moved on the putting green, and so the same procedure would apply throughout the course.
Ø This change should also make it easier for players to understand the Rules by eliminating the confusing concept of “replacing” a ball by dropping it rather than by placing it.